Cruise line plan or independent policy?

The question is whether you get money back or a voucher.

Affiliate disclosure: links to quote comparison sites and to other products and services on this page are referral links. We may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Travel insurance rates are filed with state regulators and are the same wherever you buy. Everything here is general information, not a recommendation for your situation, and not medical, legal or financial advice. Dollar amounts, percentages and time limits are typical industry ranges given for illustration, not the terms of any particular plan. The policy document controls.

At checkout the cruise line offers you its protection plan for a tidy per-person figure, already in the cart. It is convenient and sometimes it is the right choice. Here is how to tell.

Where the cruise line plan genuinely wins#

  • Pre-existing conditions. Cruise line plans frequently have no medical underwriting and no look-back period, which can make them the better option for a traveler who cannot qualify for a waiver.
  • Cancel for any reason built in. Many line plans include a cancel-for-any-reason tier as standard, paid in credit.
  • Administrative simplicity. The line cancels and credits internally, with no claim to file for the cruise portion.

Where it loses, and it usually loses here#

  • Payment in future cruise credit. A large share of line plans pay their cancellation benefit as credit toward a future sailing rather than as cash. If the reason you canceled is that you can no longer cruise, that credit is worth nothing to you.
  • It covers the line’s portion. Independently booked airfare, pre-cruise hotels and third-party excursions frequently sit outside it, and on many cruises those are a third of the total spend.
  • Thin medical and evacuation limits. Often materially lower than a comprehensive third-party plan, which matters most on exactly the itineraries where evacuation is expensive.
  • Insurer of last resort risk. If the line itself becomes insolvent, a plan administered by the line is a poor hedge against that.

Ready to price this trip? Compare quotes from many carriers side by side. Compare travel insurance quotes

How to run the comparison in five minutes#

  1. Total your full trip cost including air, hotel and independent excursions.
  2. Get a third-party quote on that full number.
  3. Put the two side by side on: cash or credit, medical maximum, evacuation limit, primary or secondary, interruption percentage, and whether non-cruise components are covered.
  4. Decide.

Often the honest answer is a third-party comprehensive policy for the whole trip. Sometimes, for a traveler with an unwaivable medical history, it is the line plan. Occasionally it is both, with the line plan for the cruise fare and an independent medical plan behind it.

Common questions

Does cruise line insurance pay cash?

Frequently not for cancellation. Many cruise line protection plans pay a future cruise credit instead of money, particularly on the cancel-for-any-reason tier. Read what the benefit pays in before accepting it at checkout.

Does the cruise line plan cover my flights?

Often only if you booked the air through the cruise line. Independently booked flights, hotels and excursions are commonly outside the plan, which is the biggest practical gap.

Phil Pavarini, Insurance AgentLicensed insurance producer (NPN 8314541, CA License No. 4481016), licensed in 49 states and the District of Columbia. Writes about insurance he has spent twenty years placing, and about trips he has actually taken.

Compare real quotes side by side

Plans from many travel insurers, filtered by the coverage that matters for your trip. Prices are filed with state regulators, so comparing does not cost you anything extra.

Compare travel insurance quotes