Affiliate disclosure: links to quote comparison sites and to other products and services on this page are referral links. We may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Travel insurance rates are filed with state regulators and are the same wherever you buy. Everything here is general information, not a recommendation for your situation, and not medical, legal or financial advice. Dollar amounts, percentages and time limits are typical industry ranges given for illustration, not the terms of any particular plan. The policy document controls.
Most articles answering this question are written by people who sell it, which is worth knowing before you read one. So here is the honest version, including the cases where the answer is no.
Two questions settle almost every case#
One: how much money would you lose if you could not go? Total the money you would lose if you never left home. If that number is small, or mostly refundable, the cancellation half of the product is not doing much for you.
Two: what happens if you need a hospital where you are going? If the answer is "my regular health insurance handles it," the medical half is not doing much either. If the answer is "Medicare stops at the border" or "the nearest hospital is a helicopter away," it is doing a great deal.
If both answers are reassuring, skip it. If either one is not, buy it. That is the whole framework.
Clearly worth it#
- Any international trip for anyone on Medicare, because Medicare provides essentially no coverage abroad
- Cruises, where onboard care is billed on the spot and evacuation is a six-figure possibility
- Trips with large non-refundable deposits booked months out
- Any itinerary that is remote, high altitude, or far from care you would accept
- Any situation where a family member’s health could realistically cause you to cancel
Ready to price this trip? Compare quotes from many carriers side by side. Compare travel insurance quotes
Probably not worth it#
- A fully refundable domestic trip on points, with your regular health insurance in force
- A weekend two hours from home by car
- A trip where your credit card already covers the specific gap and you have read the benefits guide to confirm it
That last one matters. Premium travel cards tend to carry delay, baggage and rental car protection, and a handful add a capped cancellation benefit. What they almost never carry is meaningful emergency medical or evacuation. Read the caps rather than the headline.
The honest expected-value answer#
Travel insurance, like all insurance, has a negative expected value. Insurers pay out less than they collect, or they would not exist. If you bought it on every trip forever you would lose money on average.
You buy it anyway for the same reason you carry any insurance: to convert a small certain cost into protection against a loss you could not absorb. That logic works when the potential loss is genuinely large relative to your finances, and it does not work when the potential loss is $600. Apply it accordingly, and stop feeling bad about skipping it on cheap trips.
Common questions
Do I need travel insurance for a domestic trip?
Usually less than for an international one, since your health insurance generally travels with you inside the US. The case rests on prepaid non-refundable costs. If you have significant ones, cancellation coverage still does real work.
Does my credit card replace travel insurance?
Partly. Premium cards commonly cover trip delay, baggage and rental car damage, and some include capped trip cancellation. Very few include meaningful emergency medical or evacuation coverage, which is the expensive part.
Compare real quotes side by side
Plans from many travel insurers, filtered by the coverage that matters for your trip. Prices are filed with state regulators, so comparing does not cost you anything extra.
Compare travel insurance quotes