Why you should not buy travel insurance from the company selling you the trip

The checkout plan costs more, covers less, and will not pay if the seller goes under.

Allegiant Airlines Airplane Tarmac

Affiliate disclosure: links to quote comparison sites and to other products and services on this page are referral links. We may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Travel insurance rates are filed with state regulators and are the same wherever you buy. Everything here is general information, not a recommendation for your situation, and not medical, legal or financial advice. Dollar amounts, percentages and time limits are typical industry ranges given for illustration, not the terms of any particular plan. The policy document controls.

Every booking flow now ends with a box: Protect your trip for $89? It is convenient, it is pre-filled, and for most travelers it is the wrong purchase. The plan is usually thin on medical and evacuation limits, but the deeper problem is structural. A plan sold by your travel provider almost never covers the failure of that provider. If the tour company, cruise line or airline that took your money stops operating, the policy they sold you alongside the trip is the one least likely to pay.

Financial default: the coverage that matters most and shows up least#

Financial default coverage, sometimes called supplier insolvency or bankruptcy coverage, reimburses your prepaid, non-refundable trip costs when a travel supplier ceases operations because of financial failure. Airlines, cruise lines, tour operators, charter companies and some lodging providers can be covered suppliers. It is the benefit that mattered when Thomas Cook collapsed in 2019 and when smaller tour operators folded during 2020 and 2021.

Comprehensive plans from independent insurers frequently include financial default, or make it available, with two common conditions: the policy must be bought within a set number of days of your initial trip deposit (often 14 to 21), and the failing supplier must not be the company that sold you the policy. Read that second condition again. It is the whole argument.

Many of the plans we compare include financial default coverage on their comprehensive tiers. When it is optional, it can generally be added at the time of purchase, as long as you are inside the purchase window. Ask for it by name.

Why the provider plan excludes the provider#

A travel insurer will not insure against the insolvency of its own distribution partner, and a travel company will not sell a product that pays out when it fails. So the checkbox plan carries an exclusion for the very supplier you are buying from, or omits financial default entirely. The result is a policy that covers a competitor going bankrupt but not the company holding your deposit.

Cruise line and tour operator "protection" programs go one step further. Many are not insurance at all. They are cancellation waivers: a contractual promise from the operator to refund or credit you under certain conditions. A waiver is only as good as the company behind it. If that company is in bankruptcy, the waiver is an unsecured claim in the same proceeding as your deposit.

Ready to price this trip? Compare quotes from many carriers side by side. Compare travel insurance quotes

Waiver or insurance? How to tell in ten seconds#

Look for the name of an insurance company and a policy or certificate number. Real insurance is underwritten by a licensed carrier, regulated by your state insurance department, and pays from the insurer's reserves regardless of what happens to the seller. A waiver is issued by the travel company itself, is not regulated as insurance, and often pays in future travel credit rather than cash.

Some provider offerings are hybrids: a waiver from the operator for cancellation, bundled with a small underwritten policy for medical and baggage. The medical piece is usually thin, and the cancellation piece is still a waiver. Neither part covers the operator's own failure.

You pay more for less#

Provider plans are priced as a percentage of the booking, commonly 6 to 12 percent of the trip cost, and the seller keeps a large share of that as commission. The independent market prices on trip cost, traveler age, trip length and destination, and a typical comprehensive plan lands at 4 to 8 percent of trip cost for most travelers. Younger travelers and shorter trips often land lower than that.

Put the two side by side on a $6,000 booking and the checkout plan is often $400 to $700 for a policy with $25,000 of medical coverage, no pre-existing condition waiver, no financial default and no CFAR. The same $6,000 trip on an independent plan is often $250 to $450 with $250,000 or more in medical, $500,000 or more in evacuation, and financial default included. The price gap is real, and it runs in the wrong direction: the plan that costs more covers less. Prices vary by insurer, age and trip, so run your own numbers, but the pattern holds across most bookings we have looked at.

The other reasons the checkout plan comes up short#

  • Medical and evacuation limits. Provider plans often carry $10,000 to $25,000 in medical and $50,000 or less in evacuation. Independent comprehensive plans commonly offer $100,000 to $500,000 medical and $500,000 to $1,000,000 evacuation. The evacuation number is the one that bankrupts people.
  • No pre-existing condition waiver. Most provider plans do not offer one. Independent plans do, inside the purchase window.
  • No Cancel For Any Reason. CFAR is an independent-market upgrade. The checkout plan covers the listed reasons only.
  • Covers one component. The airline plan covers the flight. The cruise plan covers the cruise. Your pre-cruise hotel, the tour extension and the other airline are on their own. An independent plan insures the whole trip cost.
  • No comparison. You are offered one plan at one price. On a comparison site you see dozens, filtered by the benefits you actually need, and the price is set by the insurer, not marked up by the seller.
  • Nobody to call. With an independent plan bought through an agent or comparison site, there is a licensed party on your side when a claim goes sideways.

When the provider plan is acceptable#

There are cases. A cheap domestic flight with no other prepaid costs, where the airline plan is $15 and you would not bother otherwise. A cruise line waiver that includes a generous cancel-for-any-reason credit you would actually use, bought on top of an independent policy for medical and evacuation. Or a trip booked inside the last week before departure, when the independent market's time-sensitive benefits are gone anyway.

The rule that holds in every case: never rely on a provider plan to cover the provider. If a single company is holding a large deposit, you want financial default coverage from an insurer that company does not control.

What to do instead#

Decline the checkbox. Note the date of your first deposit. Within 14 days, compare comprehensive plans from independent insurers, confirm financial default is included or add it, and confirm the supplier list covers the companies holding your money. Check the medical and evacuation limits against your destination. Then buy once, for the whole trip.

Compare plans and check each one for financial default coverage

Common questions

Does airline trip insurance cover the airline going bankrupt?

Almost never. The plan sold at airline checkout is typically underwritten by a third-party insurer but excludes the financial default of the airline that sold it, or omits financial default coverage entirely. An independent comprehensive plan bought within the purchase window can cover airline insolvency.

What is financial default coverage in travel insurance?

It reimburses prepaid, non-refundable trip costs when a covered travel supplier stops operating because of financial failure. It usually requires purchase within 14 to 21 days of your first trip deposit and excludes the company that sold you the policy.

Is cruise line travel protection real insurance?

Often not. Many cruise line programs are cancellation waivers issued by the cruise line itself, sometimes bundled with a small underwritten policy for medical and baggage. A waiver is not regulated as insurance and does not cover the cruise line's own failure.

Can I add financial default coverage to a plan I am comparing?

Frequently, yes. Many comprehensive plans include it on their higher tiers, and where it is optional it can usually be added at purchase, provided you are still inside the time-sensitive window after your initial deposit. Ask for it by name and check the covered supplier list.

Phil Pavarini, Insurance AgentLicensed insurance producer (NPN 8314541, CA License No. 4481016), licensed in 49 states and the District of Columbia. Writes about insurance he has spent twenty years placing, and about trips he has actually taken.

Compare real quotes side by side

Plans from many travel insurers, filtered by the coverage that matters for your trip. Prices are filed with state regulators, so comparing does not cost you anything extra.

Compare travel insurance quotes